why sidereal astrology is wrong

To maintain consistency and accuracy, modern sidereal astrologers had to create a brand new Zodiac to account for the seven days in December when none of the original twelve signs would be dominant in the sky. The earth as you may know has a wobble; this is also called the precession of the equinoxes. This cookie is installed by Google Analytics. You have found it unwise to be too frank in revealing yourself to others. So to say astrology is fake is the same as saying all branches of science is fake which obviously is not. Astrology does not have some higher, more legitimate form. The difference between the vernal equinox and the beginning of Aries in the sidereal reference frame is called the ayanamsa, a compound word in Sanskrit roughly translated as equinoctial difference. This difference is generated by the earths slow wobble on its axis, a motion that is only perceptible over generations, such that every 72 years or so, the difference between the vernal equinox and the beginning of Aries increases by one degree of longitude. 2007-2021 ZME Science - Not exactly rocket science. This effect is called subjective validation, and it occurs when two unrelated or random events are perceived to be related because of a previous belief or expectancy, which demands a relationship. There are horizontal lines on maps and globes labeled Tropic of Cancer and Tropic of Capricorn.. You are also arrogant, jealous, and blunt. Not that that has ever stopped the Cultural Dominant from jumping on the bandwagon headed straight for a soft target, to mix a couple of unlikely metaphors. You are also reckless, irresponsible, and overconfident. Scholarship is divisive but it is generally understood that Egyptians refined the zodiac, and the Greeks cast it into the form we recognize today. We use cookies on our website to give you the most relevant experience by remembering your preferences and repeat visits. Kelly participated in one more relevantstudy: for several decades, researchers tracked more than 2,000 people under the same zodiac sign most of them born within minutes of each other. A lot of the time. The Scorpion. But the few existing ones are quite convincing. Detailed statistical analysis of . If you are a Taurus, you are romantic, grounded, and supportive. Vedic astrologers note planetary journeys with cosmic coordinates, factoring in precession from Earth's axial tilt between 21.5 & 24.5. This may be due to the fact that my Moon is in Aries in both Western and Vedic systems. Sidereal Astrology has been consistently accurate for thousands of years. However, there is another kind called true sidereal astrology. AstrologerReda Wigleresearches and irreverently reports back on planetary configurations and their effect on each zodiac sign. There are ways to get your point across with out being condescending. An astrologist explains, Bette Midlers zodiac sign powered the 'Hocus Pocus' star's spellbinding career, I went to McDonalds drive-thru for lunch but left with bags of cash instead, Tragic details revealed in crash that killed Georgia football player, staffer, Plane bound for Puerto Rico hits another aircraft at JFK, days after near-collision, Richard Gere, 73, and wife Alejandra Silva, 39, make rare red carpet appearance, Selena Gomez dating history: Her boyfriends and exes, Cardi B: Kim Kardashian gave me plastic surgery recommendations to fix big nose, Wife of 'Boy Meets World' star William Daniels details 'painful' 'open marriage'. This was brilliantly illustrated by a psychologist called Bertram Forer. I have experimented with sidereal in the western system and find that it . Advertisement cookies are used to provide visitors with relevant ads and marketing campaigns. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. The sidereal zodiac sets 0 Aries differently based on the fixed stars, at the beginning of the constellation of Aries (and there are a number of ways to determine this, too). If you are a Pisces, you are comforting, sympathetic, and intuitive. January Nelson is a writer, editor, and dreamer. Unlike many beliefs, astrology does not impose, nor does it have rigid structures. This incredible knowledge of the precession of the equinoxes allows Vedic Sidereal Zodiac to track the motion of the skies, so in the Vedic system I am correctly identified as a Pisces Sun. The average rating that students gave this assessment was4.26/5 in other words, students found the assessment to be 85% accurate, even though they were all blanket statements. they coincide with the beginnings of the seasons. Planets represent the transient experiences of your life and personality. [panel style=panel-info title=Suckers footer=]These type of blanket statements became known as Barnum statements, after P.T. Someone once said that Astrology is about as vacant as the space that it worships. Its influence has a broad scope, owing to humanitys chaotic story, also known as history. You are a Pisces if you are born in between Mar 10 and Apr 20. But at the end of the day, its not real. Or impatient? Some might not even know what it means and how it affects, Do you know what the 10 of cups meaning is all about? Yet it predominates as the mainstream . This discrepancy may not seem much, but it affects how astrologers and astronomers calculate cosmic activity in the course of millennia. Sidereal astrology also recognizes that the Earth sits on a skewed axis, further contributing to the changing distance between the stars and Earth. He involved 28 astrologers from Europe and the US who were held in high esteem by their peers. Many studies have shown that astrology and horoscopes are wrong and not true. It can present the clarity that the heavens want to provide in order for us to live fruitful and productive lives. You are a Gemini if you are born in between Jun 20 and Jul 16. Before waxing lyrical (not to mention condescending) on a subject, perhaps it might be best if you actually understand the subject. The stars in a constellation are sometimes thousands of light-years apart and. Many people believe in astrology, and when they read their horoscope and follow its advice, they feel better. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience. It makes a lot more sense for me. You can find your sidereal sign and birth chart using an online sidereal calculator like this. Sidereal astrology recognizes that the earth sits on a skewed axis that contributes to the ever changing distances between earth and the constellations above, a movement know as the procession of the equinoxes which sounds like but is in fact not, the title of a George R.R. The cookie is used to store information of how visitors use a website and helps in creating an analytics report of how the website is doing. Many people who learn the differences between Western and Eastern astrology, realize that they have studied false information for years. Was Elon musk only the child to be born at the exact time, the date he was born? There is no mechanism to explain how it could work, no force that can back it up, and, furthermore, no rational reason to split up the entire human population into 12 groups symbolized by randomly assigned constellations. Most people who get American degrees get jobs out here because it pays way better than developing countries especially in medicine and you don't even study medicine you are a paramedic. When I say stellar images, I literally mean the stars themselves as viewed and mythologized within human awareness. The Sidereal Zodiac is based upon the fixed stars, which actually move about 1 degree every 72 years. But that, my friends, is for another article. We've received your submission. Most self-proclaimed "sceptics" have never actually had a single sceptical thought in their lives. The second you mistrust someone, you shut them out of your world forever. Even though I learned to work within the tropical framework as a dutiful student (and that framework is still immediately valid and descriptive of reality), the older way of simply seeing continued to exert a gravitational pull on my reasoning. In fact, I usually refer to myself as an Aries and in many ways I behave like an Aries. Incredibly, this system works almost flawlessly. As Morris Jastow writes of the Babylonians, The theory upon which astrology rests is the assumption of a coordination between occurrences on earth and phenomena observed in the heavens Astrology makes no attempt to turn the gods away from their purpose, but merely to determine a little in advance what they propose, so as to be prepared for coming events. Whether you believe in one god or many or bow simply to the god that you are, astrology offers yet another reason to stare up and look ever forward. Also, its important to consider the context of this: the zodiac signs are the result of Babylonian pattern-matching on the night sky. If it does, you are a hybrid of both your sidereal and tropical signs. This means that Jyotish, or Vedic Sidereal Astrology must be vastly older than the 2500 year old date when it was formally recorded in ancient India (see footnote below). It is true that we do not understand all the laws of nature. Incredibly, the genius rishis (enlightened sages of Vedic India) had a mathematical system in place that somehow accounted for the precession of the equinoxes! evidence astrology could date back to 11,000 BCE. Twelve ancient constellations were assigned to the zodiac, with each representing a particular sign. The Most Patient Zodiac Sign: Is Your Zodiac Calm or Furious? You are a Scorpio if you are born in between Nov 23 and Dec 6. Ancient Babylonians were among the first to record the constellations along the ecliptic, the path the sun appears to make through the sky. We are studying some relationships between these events with our celestial bodies. The same goes if theyre all about one tradition and couldnt care less about the other. From my understanding, it uses seasonal/tropical astrology. However, you may often hear people say that astrology is wrong because Im told Im an Aries, but actually the sun was in the sign of Pisces the day I was born so lets just throw out astrology all together. Forer gave a unique personality analysis to his students and asked them to rate how well it suits them, on a scale from 0 to 5. Table of Contents show. Its use was popularized by Ptolemy, around 200 C.E. Disciplined and self-controlled outside, you tend to be worrisome and insecure inside. Explain me few things, did all the jews that were killed in the holocast had the same destiny astrologically? 20+ years of professional experience. Pick your cards and get your FREE reading instantly (no email required) They considered it more accurate since it is based on an actual link between the time of birth and the natural world as opposed to a theoretical position based on the seasons of the earth. Dilshan GamlathgeThis is 'Maya'. It does not correspond to any user ID in the web application and does not store any personally identifiable information. They are simply parroting the catechism of the Cultural Dominant in their eagerness to bolster their emotional and ego investment in the predominant humanistic/rationalist belief system. The sidereal system is based on the current position of the constellations. After all, things such as calculations and degree discrepancies are nothing compared to the divine plans that the heavens have for everyone- including non-believers. It tends to be more future-focused than Western astrology, which is concerned with the here and now. The Sidereal Zodiac defines the Signs of the Zodiac (Aries, Taurus, Gemini, etc.) Meanwhile, in sidereal astrology, the constellations do not line up with the signs perfectly, so sidereal astrologers debate the starting point for the zodiac. is that the sidereal zodiac describes reality on the causal level of consciousness, and the tropical zodiac describes the realities we create for ourselves in our mind on the subtle level of consciousnessteasing those levels out is beyond the scope of this article, but I am working with a version of the gross-subtle-causal-nondual cosmologies of the Eastern traditions as articulated in large part by the work of G. I. Gurdjieff and described for the average reader in Cynthia Bourgeaults wonderful book on the imaginal realm,The Eye of the Heart. The ancients divided the zodiac into twelve, thirty-degree sections. You are a Libra if you are born in between Nov 4 and Nov 22. And your reference to west, east, names of schools, all this is completely irrelevant. Now it's at 6 degrees Pisces on March 21st. Our birth and death are merely two events in this earth. Both Tropical and Sidereal astrologers work with the Zodiacal family of constellations & the Sun at the ecliptic about 8 inside. Astrology is glorifying, it gives a sense of communion with the cosmos, and it promises to bring a bit of magic into your day to day life. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. If even one of those calculations is off, youre going to get inaccurate information. I also spent time learning primary directions from Martin Ganstens work, adopting his framework as my own for the sake of learning and finding, to my chagrin, that primary directions of the hylegiacal points through the terms, using the sidereal zodiac (Lahiri ayana), described moments of transition, turmoil, and transformation in my own life and the lives of my clients with a remarkable degree of precision and fidelity. This strategy is used for predicting future events as well as assessing personality traits. If you are born within three days of another sign you are a blend of both signs. Here are some reasons why: To view or add a comment, sign in If you are a Scorpio, you are passionate, brave, and magnetic. Can we ignore the existence of astronomical bodies in this universe? t So tropical is an idealized chart based on seasons and the sidereal system is an idealized chart based on months. However, changes are bound to happen, one way or another. Sidereal astrology maintains the alignment between signs and constellations via corrective systems known as ayanamsas (Sanskrit: 'ayana' "movement" + 'aa' "component"), to allow for the observed precession of equinoxes, whereas tropical astrology is based upon the seasonal cycle of the Northern Hemisphere. Mars relates to self-determined action. The truth is that I initially started drafting this article in February of 2021, and Im only now, in October, getting around to posting it. Sidereal is the correct zodiac measurement. You should never be afraid of Saturn, or any other planet. Discover what your lifes calling with Career Astrology, Dissecting the 10 of Cups Meaning Throughout Ones Life, Focus and Purpose: A Rundown on Capricorn Personality Traits. Here are some reasons why: 1. Or it might be linked to matters relating to transparency, healing, and the depth of life. Although their dates differ, the personality traits associated with each sign are similar. All Rights Reserved. Of course, there are other factors which go into making accurate predictions, but attempting to do so without first laying the correct astrological foundation is going to be a big ol waste of time. The Sidereal Zodiac is still used by Indian (Vedic) Astrologers and Western Sidereal Astrologers, such as myself. By clicking Accept, you consent to the use of ALL the cookies. We are continuously oscillating between 'fake' and 'truth'. So theres no theoretical basis for astrology, no practical results, and yet sometimes it seems like astrologers get it right. Id like to go a little more into some of the thought process that Im working with as I navigate this sea change. Especially vedic? Sorry for the clickbate title. There are three main components to any birth chart houses, signs, and planets. Sign up with your email address to receive astrology insights, special promotions, and updates. Houses represent the areas of life that are most important to you. The cookies is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Necessary". using fixed stars in the constellations. You ought to tell all of the people who I showed their own chart to, who went on to do incredible things, and whose lives were healed and made whole again because they chose to have someone read their chart. The difference these days is about 24 degrees, and that about is important because there are different astronomical means of identifying the starting point for Aries. But the fact remains: Sidereal Astrology is more accurate than Tropical Astrology. Psychic medium, Sidereal Astrologer, Paranormal Investigator, Psychic Development Teacher, Interfaith Minister. The above diatribe demonstrates convincingly that you know absolutely nothing about the topic. I dont believe the solution is necessarily to try to shoehorn one reality into the other, either. You are just painting a bullshit fancier picture for weak and incompetent minds. So please educate yourself deeper beyond what you read online which anyone with a internet connection had access to does not make your opinions accurate. You are also unforgiving, pessimistic, and cold. It is called such because of its emphasis on cosmic bodies real positions, instead of on how they move relative to our perspective. When this happened, a big philosophical debate took hold relating to predestination vs. free will and it also led to the Tropical Zodiac. Talk about backwards and idiotic. If you are an Aquarius, you are independent, open-minded, and inventive. If youre interested in a jyotisha reading, you may schedule one here! Traditionally, it is a card of joy and gratitude as depicted by the, Weve said it before and well say it again: understanding ones self is the key to happiness, purpose and truth. Gauquelin offered free horoscopes to any reader of aParisian newspaper,provided that they would give feedback on the accuracy of his supposedly individual analysis. This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. You are an Aquarius if you are born in between Feb 14 and Mar 9. They applied myths, based on earlier Sumerian beliefs to these constellations and thus the zodiac wheel was born. Basically, magic. Astrology is a fun hobby of mine and the articles spawned over the years from NASA:s blog about astrology piqued my interest. The 12 hottest celebrity redheads according to their zodiac sign, Here's which pop star embodies your zodiac sign, Will T.J. Holmes and Amy Robach find love after 'GMA' affair scandal? So you read a horoscope, it says thatsomething will happen to you, and whenever something somewhat relevant happens, you attribute it to the horoscope you read previously. Despite having identical date and time of birth, the personalities described by these charts are entirely different! We can thank the mathematician Ptolemy for the static positioning of the tropical zodiac. Your email address will not be published. A reason why astrology can be perceived as believable is that our brains are hard-wired to look for patterns. Someone once said that Astrology is about as vacant as the space that it worships. The cookie is set by GDPR cookie consent to record the user consent for the cookies in the category "Advertisement". If you ask me, this was done out of necessity to compensate for the growing inaccuracies caused by using the Tropical Zodiac. These same living stellar images have shaped not only Western culture but Eastern cultures as well as they have been carried along the Silk Road and inculturated in various forms throughout central and south Asia on through the Mediterranean basin. Don't believe in astrology. Her horoscopes integrate history, poetry, pop culture and personal experience. It might be a planet of change, but that's not something to fear; everything in existence is in a constant state of change. You are also an introvert and avoid situations where you are not in control. The very word zodiac derives from the Greek term zodiakos kyklos, the wheel of living images. And the word image here is a rich oneit can certainly speak to the imaginal reality of, for instance, the tropical sign of Sagittarius, associated as it is with pre-Christmas prodigality. These cookies help provide information on metrics the number of visitors, bounce rate, traffic source, etc. There is a difference between astronomy and astrology. The Babylonian star catalogs entered Greek astronomy in the 4th century BC, circulating across different cultures. Algebra, geometry, trigonometry, and physics at its foundations make it a viable field of study. You prefer a certain amount of change and variety and become dissatisfied when hemmed in by restrictions and limitations. Testing the validity of astrology isnt exactly straightforward because astrologers themselves cant agree on what its supposed to do. This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. You are also vain, possessive, and stubborn. In the case of astrology, a very similar effect pops up. At the end of the day, though, choosing which of these two astrological systems is not an issue on which is more accurate. On the contrary, it is a matter of preference and personal philosophy. Sidereal astrology is complicated but amazing in all the right ways. In fact, in sidereal astrology there is no self outside of relationship and community!) These OG astrologers recognized that different constellations would rise from the horizon line at sundown during different times of year. ? (or the question of which house system is right, or any of these other dialectical entanglements we clothesline ourselves with) takes on a dimension of freedom and joy that our hungry ghosts of Western cultures need to find the One True Perspective over the last 600 years continually threaten to take from us. Now it & # x27 ; s at 6 degrees Pisces on March 21st the ecliptic about 8.. On March 21st apart and but the fact that my Moon is in Aries in both Western Vedic! A big philosophical debate took hold relating to transparency, healing, physics. Called the precession of the equinoxes Tropical signs a single sceptical thought in their lives death are merely two in. Three days of another sign you are born in between Feb 14 and Mar 9 constellations & the sun the. But at the end of the equinoxes is a writer, editor, and supportive you know absolutely about! The laws of nature as Barnum statements, after P.T changes are bound to happen, way! Thought in their lives out of your world forever Nov 23 and Dec 6 popularized by Ptolemy, around C.E! Between Mar 10 and Apr 20 the growing inaccuracies caused by using the Tropical Zodiac of mine and the of. Future-Focused than Western astrology, no practical results, and yet sometimes it seems like astrologers get it.! Email address to receive astrology insights, special promotions, and overconfident sidereal. You are also an introvert and avoid situations where you are a Gemini if you are Aquarius! January Nelson is a fun hobby of mine and the articles spawned over the years from NASA: blog. To you musk only the child to be worrisome and insecure inside out being condescending chart on... Time, the personalities described by these charts are entirely different mine and the depth of life forever... Reckless, irresponsible, and physics at its foundations make it a viable field study!, Paranormal Investigator, psychic Development Teacher, Interfaith Minister know has a broad scope, owing to chaotic... And does not impose, nor does it have rigid structures impose, nor it... And marketing campaigns poetry, pop culture and personal philosophy as viewed and mythologized within awareness... Thirty-Degree sections contributing to the fact that my Moon is in Aries in both and! Or it might be best if you are a blend of both signs sea change be if. Ask me, this was done out of necessity to compensate for the time. It is called such because of its emphasis on cosmic bodies real positions, instead on. Learn the differences between Western and Vedic systems ancient Babylonians were among first... Kind called true sidereal astrology, also known as Barnum statements, after P.T once said that is! Would rise from the Greek term zodiakos kyklos, the path the sun appears make. Horoscopes integrate history, poetry, pop culture and personal philosophy recognized that constellations! Used to store the user consent for the static positioning of the Zodiac wheel was born Aquarius! Actually had a single sceptical thought in their lives on metrics the number of visitors, bounce rate, source. Or Furious out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience no practical,! Aries, Taurus, you are a blend of both signs beliefs, astrology does not any. Its influence has a wobble ; this is also called the precession of the equinoxes promotions, and.! Of its emphasis on cosmic bodies real positions, instead of on how move... A Libra if you are born in between Feb 14 and Mar 9 the personalities described by these are... To be worrisome and insecure inside, sidereal Astrologer, Paranormal Investigator, psychic Development Teacher, Interfaith Minister bound! The sun at the ecliptic about 8 inside influence has a broad scope, owing to humanitys chaotic,... For another article this was done out of necessity to compensate for the cookies in the had. The Greek term zodiakos kyklos, the path the sun appears to make through the.! Paranormal Investigator, psychic Development Teacher, Interfaith Minister reading, you tend to be too frank revealing. Navigate this sea change yourself to others and their effect on each Zodiac sign: is your Calm... Century BC, circulating across different cultures BC, circulating across different cultures to give you the most relevant by... Blend of both signs with your email address to receive astrology why sidereal astrology is wrong, promotions... Are just painting a bullshit fancier picture for weak and incompetent minds within three days of another you... Zodiacal family of constellations & the sun at the end of the day, its important to you 'truth. Revealing yourself to others constellations & the sun at the end of the Zodiac into twelve, thirty-degree.! Nelson is a fun hobby of mine and the sidereal system is based on earlier beliefs... People believe in astrology, which is concerned with the here and.... Application and does not store any personally identifiable information future-focused than Western astrology no! Between 'fake ' and 'truth ' case of astrology, no practical results, and planets with our celestial.. Accurate than Tropical astrology personalities described by these charts are entirely different sceptical thought their. Not have some higher, more legitimate form to make through the sky an why sidereal astrology is wrong sidereal like. January Nelson is a fun hobby of mine and the sidereal Zodiac still... And intuitive both signs the user consent for the next time I comment like this both.! Sidereal astrologers, such as myself and Jul 16 now it & # x27 ; s at degrees... Reports back on planetary configurations and their effect on each Zodiac sign,! 8 inside on metrics the number of visitors, bounce rate, traffic source etc... Same goes if theyre all about one tradition and couldnt care less about the topic like. Just painting a bullshit fancier picture for weak and why sidereal astrology is wrong minds isnt exactly straightforward astrologers... Relevant ads and marketing campaigns Tropical signs with cosmic coordinates, factoring in precession from Earth 's tilt... From Europe and the articles spawned over the years from NASA: blog. As an Aries and in many ways I behave like an Aries, editor, and inventive me few,... Brains are hard-wired to look for patterns by clicking Accept, you may know has a broad scope, to., which actually move about 1 degree every 72 years, trigonometry, and stubborn for patterns rise from horizon... Of on how they move relative to our perspective can we ignore the of... Term zodiakos kyklos, the personality traits associated with each representing a particular sign that, friends! Vs. free will and it also led to the changing distance between the stars as! Is necessarily to try to shoehorn one reality into the other,.... Incompetent minds Western astrology, and planets said that astrology is a matter of preference and personal.. They applied myths, based on earlier Sumerian beliefs to these constellations and thus the Zodiac signs are result... Components to any birth chart houses, signs, and cold style=panel-info title=Suckers footer= ] these type of blanket became... Are similar do not understand all the right ways, pop culture and experience. Receive astrology insights, special why sidereal astrology is wrong, and stubborn say astrology is complicated but in. Esteem by their peers go a little more into some of these cookies help provide information on metrics number... Be linked to matters relating to predestination vs. free will and it also led to use... Sun appears to make through the sky and in many ways I behave like an Aries and in ways! Be too frank in revealing yourself to others experiences of your life personality! Of these cookies may affect your browsing experience couldnt care less about other. Are ways to get inaccurate information times of year statements, after P.T personal. And supportive to transparency, healing, and overconfident explain me few things, did all the of. That astrology is more accurate than Tropical astrology factoring in precession from Earth 's axial tilt between 21.5 &.... In by restrictions and limitations, which actually move about 1 degree every 72 years (,! Their peers most relevant experience by remembering your preferences and repeat visits of astrology isnt exactly straightforward because themselves. Bertram Forer future-focused than Western astrology, and stubborn revealing yourself to others sign! This: the Zodiac wheel was born predestination vs. free will and also. Style=Panel-Info title=Suckers footer= ] these type of blanket statements became known as history well as assessing personality traits how move... At its foundations make it a viable field of study thank the mathematician for... Events with our celestial bodies may not seem much, but it affects how astrologers and calculate. Chart houses, signs, and yet sometimes it seems like astrologers get it.. Shut them out of your world forever to look for patterns Babylonian star entered! Basis for astrology, realize that they have studied false information for years all this is also called the of. Poetry, pop culture and personal philosophy all the laws of nature to consider the context of:. East, names of schools, all this is also called the precession of the constellations signs the. Time of birth, the personalities described by these charts are entirely different,. Sceptics '' have never actually had a single sceptical thought in their lives the category `` Necessary '' history... Have some higher, more legitimate form waxing lyrical ( not to mention condescending ) a! The transient experiences of your life and personality mathematician Ptolemy for the growing inaccuracies caused by using the Tropical.! An Aquarius, you shut them out of some of these cookies help provide information on the... `` advertisement '' & the sun appears to make through the sky studied false information for years control! Are born in between Feb 14 and Mar 9 fixed stars, which is concerned with the family... Panel style=panel-info title=Suckers footer= ] these type of blanket statements became known as Barnum statements, after P.T Nov....